Home Opinion There is No "One Size Fits All" Approach to Management

There is No "One Size Fits All" Approach to Management


Working in the emergency field is incredibly exhilarating, especially when emergencies can be a life and death situation. Those responding to 911 calls can have a tremendous influence over a serious situation intervening to save lives and property.

While many employees are intrinsically motivated, the management of an emergency team needs to be comprised of individuals who understand how to motivate and lead others - but, all teams are different.

Motivation alone is a particularly intricate concept because individuals are motivated by many, many different things. Thus, there is a vast amount of scholarly literature exploring numerous aspects of motivation and how it works for individuals, teams, and organizations at large.

Therefore, a good manager needs to consider how to motivate their team based on the strengths and weaknesses of their employees, and how management strategies will potentially work differently for employees on an emergency team.

Management is always a delicate balance with numerous factors coming into play.

Management Advice

Peter Economy wrote about nine ways to motivate a team. In the list, Economy includes items like “pay your people what they’re worth” and “set clear goals.” 

In the world of emergency management, both of these items are rather complex and, perhaps, may not be motivational tools that would work well for an emergency team. Most managers want to pay their employees well in the emergency field - certainly they should with the amount of certifications and experience many emergency employees have. However, many local municipalities struggle with an appropriate budget unable to pay their employees what they probably should be paid. (A related article discusses this issue in a similar light).

Further, this can’t necessarily be a motivational tool for many emergency managers.

Setting Goals

Setting clear goals, as mentioned by Economy, is also a rather difficult concept for many teams and organizations – let alone those that work in the emergency field. In many team environments, this is an important aspect, and is certainly a good way to manage employees. In the emergency world though, it may not necessarily be something that can be used as a motivational tool.

Further, goals are actually very complicated and can present numerous issues to a team when they’re not constructed correctly. In the scholarly article Goals Gone Wild, Ordonez et al examine the literature writing that the construction of goals can have a detrimental affect on an organization – especially if the goals are vague, are too complicated, or have unrealistic deadlines. They argue that a poorly constructed goal, even with the best intentions, can work against an organization producing disastrous results.

When it comes to emergency management, it becomes increasingly important for those in charge to review articles like the one written by Peter Economy and decide whether or not these specific factors will work well for their team. In many cases, management suggestions many not work with an emergency team because it is a specialized team that is vastly different from a team in a “normal” organization.

Allison G. S. Knox Passionate about the issues affecting ambulances and disaster management, Allison focuses on Emergency Management and Emergency Medical Services policy. Allison has taught at the undergraduate level since 2010. Prior to teaching, she worked in a level-one trauma center emergency department and for a member of Congress in Washington, D.C. She holds four master’s degrees in Emergency Management, National Security Studies, International Relations, and History; a Graduate Certificate in Homeland Security; and a Bachelor of Arts in Political Science. Allison is an Emergency Medical Technician, Lifeguard, and Lifeguard Instructor, and is trained in Technical Large Animal Emergency Rescue. She serves on the Board of Trustees for Pi Gamma Mu International Honor Society as Chancellor of the Southeast Region, Vice Chair of the Tactical Emergency Medical Support Committee with the International Public Safety Association, and serves as the Advocacy Coordinator of Virginia with the National Association of Emergency Medical Technicians. She is also a member of several committees including the Editorial Committee with APCO, the Rescue Task Force Committee with the International Public Safety Association, and the Advocacy Committee with the National Association of Emergency Medical Technicians. She also serves as Chair of the Leadership Development Program for the 2020 Pi Gamma Mu Triennial Convention. Allison has published several book reviews and continues to write about issues affecting ambulances, emergency management, and homeland security.